Home Equity Loan vs. 401(K) Loan -- Which Should You Choose

Home Equity Loan vs. 401(K) Loan

You've finally decided to add that patio you've always wanted to your home. Now you can enjoy barbecue outdoors and get a little fresh air every now and again. But how are you going to pay for it? If you're like most people, you don't have cash for home repairs just lying around the house. You'll have to borrow. So where should you go to borrow? Mortgage rates are low these days, so a home equity loan would be pretty affordable, as would a home equity line of credit (HELOC) if you have a number of remodeling projects in mind.

Then it occurs to you -- "What about my 401(K) money? I can get good terms on a 401(K) loan and borrow the money from myself!" That seems like a good idea. You can borrow the money from yourself and pay yourself back with interest! What could be better than that?.

On the surface, borrowing from your retirement savings may seem like a better idea than taking out a home equity loan. The terms are good either way, and the interest rates are probably comparable. So, why not borrow from your 401(K) account?.

There are several reasons why it may not be desirable to borrow from your retirement account:.

  • Most Americans fail to save enough for retirement, so borrowing from your retirement fund may leave you short later should you default. No one wants to be broke when they retire.
  • If you have a diversified 401(K) account, you will probably be earning interest on your retirement money. In fact, the interest rate you are earning on your retirement fund may exceed the interest rate you would pay for a home equity loan. In that case, you take out a home equity loan, leave the retirement money where it is, and you should earn a net gain between the two.
  • If your retirement fund is earning good interest, and in the late 1990's many were earning upwards of 20% per year, then borrowing on your principal could hurt you tremendously in the long run. Due to the nature of compounding, the amount you lose by borrowing from your retirement account could be far more than simply the sum of the loan amount plus interest.
  • The interest on a home equity loan is tax deductible, up to $100,000. The interest on a 401(K) loan is not.


    • There are certainly some circumstances where you might benefit from borrowing from retirement funds instead of taking out a second mortgage, but those situations are fairly rare. A substantially higher interest rate on the home equity loan than the 401(K) loan would be one such example. If in doubt, you should consult with a financial planner.

    ©Copyright 2005 by Retro Marketing. Charles Essmeier is the owner of Retro Marketing, a firm devoted to informational Websites, such as http://www.HomeEquityHelp.net/ and http://www.End-Your-Debt.com/

    In The News:

    Google News
    Updated : Fri, 29 Aug 2008 06:25:11 GMT

    Storm could postpone Republican convention - Los Angeles Times


    radiojamaica.com
    Storm could postpone Republican convention
    Los Angeles Times - 1 hour ago
    By Maeve Reston, Los Angeles Times Staff Writer BLOOMINGTON, MINN. -- As the political spotlight shifts to the upcoming Republican convention in Minneapolis-St.
    McCain camp closely watching Gustav CNN Political Ticker
    GOP could delay convention if Gustav hits MarketWatch
    Houston Chronicle - USA Today - Pensacola News Journal
    all 139 news articles

    Publ.Date : Fri, 29 Aug 2008 05:25:11 GMT

    NBC Rules Wednesday Night - New York Times

    NBC Rules Wednesday Night
    New York Times - 1 hour ago
    By BENJAMIN TOFF; Compiled by Julie Bloom “America’s Got Talent” helped NBC in the ratings on Wednesday, making the network No.
    Obama's breathtaking show transcended politics The Associated Press
    Ratings dip on DNC's night 3 Variety
    Denver Post - Multichannel News - MarketWatch - New York Daily News
    all 661 news articles

    Publ.Date : Fri, 29 Aug 2008 05:00:29 GMT

    Scientists Reprogram Adult Cells' Function - Washington Post


    Chatter Shmatter
    Scientists Reprogram Adult Cells' Function
    Washington Post - 10 hours ago
    By Rob Stein Through a series of painstaking experiments involving mice, the Harvard biologists pinpointed three crucial molecular switches that, when flipped, completely convert a common cell in the pancreas into the more precious insulin-producing ...
    Researchers Report Advances in Cell Conversion Technique New York Times
    Diabetes researchers convert pancreas cells to produce insulin Los Angeles Times
    USA Today - Boston Globe - Bloomberg
    all 457 news articles

    Publ.Date : Thu, 28 Aug 2008 19:41:39 GMT

    South Carolina survives 4 interceptions - The Associated Press


    Washington Post
    South Carolina survives 4 interceptions
    The Associated Press - 1 hour ago
    COLUMBIA, SC (AP) - Steve Spurrier just can't avoid quarterback controversies. South Carolina's coach had intended since April for junior Tommy Beecher to lead the Gamecocks.
    NC State gets off to a rough start Winston-Salem Journal
    Locker Room Report: Tom O'Brien CanesTime.com
    N.C. State University Technician Online - Memphis Commercial Appeal - FayObserver.com - Burlington Times News
    all 270 news articles

    Publ.Date : Fri, 29 Aug 2008 04:31:00 GMT

    A Georgia School System Loses Its Accreditation - New York Times


    ABC News
    A Georgia School System Loses Its Accreditation
    New York Times - 2 hours ago
    By ROBBIE BROWN ATLANTA - A county school system in metropolitan Atlanta on Thursday became the nation’s first in nearly 40 years to lose its accreditation, and the governor removed four of its school board members for ethics violations.
    Clayton schools’ fears are realized Atlanta Journal Constitution
    Group: Troubled Ga. district loses accreditation International Herald Tribune
    ABC News - The Associated Press - News/Talk 750 WSB - WLOS
    all 441 news articles

    Publ.Date : Fri, 29 Aug 2008 04:08:34 GMT

    Clark to speak with Minister over fraud claims - ABC Online


    TVNZ
    Clark to speak with Minister over fraud claims
    ABC Online - 2 hours ago
    By New Zealand correspondent Kerri Ritchie New Zealand's Prime Minister Helen Clark is under increasing pressure to sack her Foreign Affairs Minister, Winston Peters, who is being investigated over undeclared political donations.
    Peters steps down from Government New Zealand Herald
    NZ foreign minister under pressure to resign International Herald Tribune
    AFP - National Business Review - The Dominion Post - TVNZ
    all 309 news articles

    Publ.Date : Fri, 29 Aug 2008 03:48:29 GMT

    Concerns remain as salmonella outbreak comes to an end - Los Angeles Times

    Concerns remain as salmonella outbreak comes to an end
    Los Angeles Times - 3 hours ago
    The produce industry says the FDA search for the source, which shifted suspicion from tomatoes to jalapeño and serrano peppers, shattered consumer confidence and cost it millions.
    Salmonella Outbreak Is Said to Be Over New York Times
    Feds: Worst of salmonella is over Bradenton Herald
    AHN - Food Consumer - CNN - The Associated Press
    all 560 news articles

    Publ.Date : Fri, 29 Aug 2008 02:43:58 GMT

    RSStoBlog
    RSS For Web Pages


    PARLOT::Ebooks, Scripts, Websites, and more...

    Adsense websites

    Consolidate Debt With A Home Equity Loan

    If you are a home owner who is having to... Read More

    Why Choose a Home Equity Loan?

    There are many reasons for choosing a home equity loan.... Read More

    Refinance Online

    If you want a low interest, low payment mortgage refinance,... Read More

    Shopping for A Mortgage? Do Your Homework First

    If you happen to be shopping around for a mortgage,... Read More

    Mortgage: Effective Household Investment for Financial Autonomy

    If finances had a copyright, we would have bought it... Read More

    Bankers Dont Want You to Know That You Pay for Your No Cost Home Loan Forever

    With mortgage rates continuing on a downward trend, the competition... Read More

    How to Save Money by Using an Independent Commercial Mortgage Broker

    Being a creature of habit can cost you plenty when... Read More

    UK Mortages: A Guide Through The Maze

    Types of UK MortgagesYou may be wasting your money with... Read More

    Financing the Purchase of Foreclosed Homes

    Homes that have been foreclosed can be one of the... Read More

    How Good a Deal Is Your Banks Mortgage Insurance Plan?

    When you go to the bank to get a mortgage,... Read More

    6 Things to Consider Before Refinancing

    Perhaps you're a homeowner in need of some quick cash.Maybe... Read More

    Home Equity Can Create a Never-ending Money Cycle

    What could you do with $10,000? Well, you can have... Read More

    FHA Mortgage: When Your Downpayment is a Gift

    There has been so much fraud discovered in the FHA... Read More

    Who Could Benefit From A Reverse Mortgage?

    What is a "Reverse Mortgage?"Also known as a Home Equity... Read More

    Residential Mortgages ? a Step Ahead on the Property Ladder

    Doesn't Residential mortgage give the impression that they are a... Read More

    Home Equity Loans - 5 Useful Application Tips

    Obtaining a home equity loan does not have to be... Read More

    Bad Credit Mortgage Refinance - Should I, Shouldnt I?

    It is a common financial scenario across households in the... Read More

    How to Find Cheap Home Improvement Loans

    If you have home improvements that you'd like to see... Read More

    Mortgage Brokers or Banks: Which is Right For You?

    When you're looking for a home loan, you might work... Read More

    Unlock your Home Loan Piggy Bank

    With the recent sharp increase in property values your current... Read More

    A Home Loan Can Help You Own Your Dream Home

    Owning your dream home need not just be a dream.... Read More

    Adjustable Rate Mortgage - How They Work?

    How does an ARM work.The borrowers interest rate is determined... Read More

    Some Mortgage Loans are Available with Absolutely no Money Needed From You

    Today, FHA will loan up to 97 percent of the... Read More

    Low Income Home Loans - FHA and VA Mortgage Loans Can Help You Get Approved

    If you have low income and are looking to get... Read More

    Reverse Mortgages: When Is One Right For You?

    How do you know if a reverse mortgage is right... Read More