Is the IronPort Whitelist Actually An Extortion Tactic?
It appears that Mr. Gates' prophetic prediction that charging marketers to send email across the Microsoft email networks (MSN and Hotmail) to cut down on Sp*m is about to come true.
According to CIO Today, Microsoft is now employing "IronPort Anti-Spam Technology."
"IronPort" is a paid "white-list" for people who send "mass email" (including newsletter publishers, ezine publishers, affiliate managers, mini-course operators, and basically anyone who has a list of opt-in emails).
If you send any type of email where you do a broadcast to everyone on your list, this applies to you.
If you want your email broadcasts to get through their filters, you must pay a hefty fee and post a "bond."
Here are some facts about this developing story:
1. They charge by how much email you send a month, but the minimum charge is a:
$375 Application Fee, plus
$500 Annual License Fee, plus
$500 "Bond" fee.
That's $1,375.00 just to get in the game.
If you want to see the complete breakdown, go here https://www.bondedsender.com/fees.jsp
2. If you go over the "complaint" threshold of 1 complaint per month, then they will debit $20 from your bond fee for each complaint to "fine" you for being naughty.
Now that sounds good on the surface, but here's a scenario to try on for size:
Your competitor / enemy / Net "psycho" signs up for 50 fr~e email accounts at HotMail and complains about you every month when you send your newsletter.
49 complaints (50 - 1 allowed complaint) times $20 a complaint comes out to $980 in fines.
Now, can you dispute the fines? Sure, absolutely!
But how much will you lose in time, energy and effort disputing the allegations? (My guess is, a whole lot more than that.)
You can check out all the "rules" here https://www.bondedsender.com/fees.jsp
Here are the details of the program straight from the horse's mouth... https://www.bondedsender.com
Here's my take on this whole thing (which dropped on me out of the blue today):
First, don't get me wrong... I hate sp~m with a passion!
I spend at least an hour a day fighting it (down from 3 hours a day just a few weeks ago before I shut down about 2 dozen email addresses that got harvested by spambots over the last few years).
With that said, this whole "IronPort" thing sounds and smells to me like "white list" extortion.
Why?
Here's the basic premise: "Pay to get your email through our filters, or else you run the very likely risk of not getting your email through at all."
In fact, here's a *direct quote* from their website https://www.bondedsender.com/faqs/sender.jsp:
"What happens if I don't bond my email? You're rolling the dice and taking your chances with spam filters, black lists and bulk folders. Some days all of your email may be delivered; other days 30-50% could be blocked."
Kind of reminds you of a cheesy mafia movie on late night TV:
Me: "Hey Bugsy, what happens if I don't pay my 'protection' money this month? What if I stand up to you and refuse to pay?"
Bugsy: "Well, maybe nothin' will happen to you because the Boss ain't payin' attention when I tell him you decided not to pay. On the other hand, maybe I'll just smack you around a little bit... or maybe-- I'll BREAK YOUR LEG with this baseball bat! Go ahead and not pay us... then we'll see what happens!"
Now, back to my question: "Why should I have to pay a huge fee to send email to people who have opted in to my lists?"
The argument from Microsoft (and soon to be other ISP's) is that the uncontrolled sp~m on the web is costing them a lot of money to deliver email nobody wants to read.
Well, if that's the case, aren't email users shelling out cash or credit to pay their ISPs for email services (mine charges me $40 a month for cable), or paying for free services like HotMail or Yahoo Mail through viewing advertising on every page?
I was under the impression we were already paying to receive email... and last time I checked, there was no place to put a stamp!
Okay, even if we make it past that and we accept the argument that legitimate emailers should have to pay a fee in order to get on that big "whitelist in the sky" somewhere... there are still two very important considerations here:
1. First, what about the little guy who starts doing really well?
You know, the small newsletter publisher who puts out a great ezine or fr-e report or whatever, and gets a lot of subscribers and then wants to broadcast email to them on a regular basis?
Let's say they start making $20,000.00 a year from their ezine... are they now supposed to shell out 6-10% of their earnings in order to get their messages through? (And that's if they never get a fine!)
Do they have to be penalized for being successful?
Apparently so if this system gains widespread acceptance by all the big ISP's and email service providers!
2. Second, what about the high potential for abuse at the hands of unethical competitors and just plain jerks that populate the Internet!
I know it might seem hard to believe, but there are psychos out there who will sign up for a bunch of free email accounts just so they can make trouble.
(This is not paranoia! I had a user who signed up, definitely opted-in from my website, had the emails routed through a SpamCop address so I got blacklisted by SpamCop until I could get it straightened out. Oh, and guess who owns SpamCop... IronPort, that's who!)
Now, some idiot making waves with 100 email accounts won't put a dent in the pockets of most big players in the email arena... for them it'll just be a business expense.
But for the case of the "little" guy, fighting that potential abuse and those fees could seriously cripple and even kill a fledgling enterprise... and that, in my opinion, is a serious problem.
In my opinion, all this is going to do is cut out the little guy and make it easier for big companies to email the hell out of the rest of us.
A small newsletter publisher will find it cost-prohibitive to pay for the service, and some giant company will just keep pumping the email out because they have the staff and resources to fight the inevitable complaints.
And let's face it, if a big company is paying a $10,000.00 a year licensing fee plus posting a $4,000.00 bond, how aggressive do you think the IronTrust people will really be to get rid of them?
In my opinion, not very.
In conclusion: Despite my ranting, I actually think this is a step in the right direction (albeit a wobbly, drunken, and inconvenient step).
Something has to be done to fight spam.
However, at this point, this whole system has (in my opinion) too many unanswered questions, especially for us little guys.
Namely:
- Do I really need to do this if I'm a little guy operating and growing a newsletter?
- What happens if I get unfounded spam complaints?
- At what level does it make financial sense for me to do this?
- What if my newsletter isn't a big profit generator... am I supposed to give up the revenue I do create just to get my emails through?
To their apparent credit, Yahoo! is also trying to pioneer a solution, but this one doesn't appear (at this point) like it will cost publishers or subscribers any money (and I like the sound of that). http://antispam.yahoo.com/domainkeys
But with so much at stake (on both sides), this issue is a far cry from any satisfactory resolution.
Stay tuned for further updates as events warrant...
About The Author
Jim Edwards is a syndicated newspaper columnist and the co-author of an amazing new ebook that will teach you how to use fr^e articles to quickly drive thousands of targeted visitors to your website or affiliate links...
Need MORE TRAFFIC to your website or affiliate links? "Turn Words Into Traffic" reveals the secrets for driving Thousands of NEW visitors to your website or affiliate links... without spending a dime on advertising! Click Here> http://www.turnwordsintotraffic.com
 Google News Updated : Sat, 11 Oct 2008 23:50:53 GMT Got $700 Billion? Sweat the Details - New York Times
New York Times - The bailout plan gives Henry M. Paulson Jr., the Treasury secretary, three broad choices in buying assets. By ALAN S. BLINDER THE House of Representatives was against the bailout bill before it was for it. US firms up plan to buy into banks to stem crisis Paulson Indicates Need to Purchase Bank Equity `Soon as We Can' Publ.Date : Sat, 11 Oct 2008 20:39:07 GMT World is united to tackle financial crisis, IMF says - MarketWatch
MarketWatch - By Rex Nutting WASHINGTON (MarketWatch) -- Financial policymakers from 180 nations around the world are united in their resolve to tackle the financial crisis, Youssef Boutros-Ghali, head of the International Monetary Fund's policy committee, ... G7 nations face going cap in hand to China Finance officials comments at IMF meetings Publ.Date : Sat, 11 Oct 2008 21:23:46 GMT US space tourist set for blast-off - Reuters
Reuters - By Maria Golovnina BAIKONUR, Kazakhstan (Reuters) - US video game magnate Richard Garriott will blast off into space aboard a Russian spaceship on Sunday watched by his father, a NASA astronaut who went into space at the height of the Cold War. US space tourist set for launch Russian space chief reassures US partners Publ.Date : Sat, 11 Oct 2008 23:10:50 GMT Gay Marriage Is Ruled Legal in Connecticut - New York Times
New York Times - In Hartford, Crystal Pretzman of Willimantic, Conn., celebrated the State Supreme Court's decision to legalize same-sex marriage. Video: Connecticut Court Allows Gay Marriage Marriage ruling not the end of debate in Conn. Publ.Date : Sat, 11 Oct 2008 18:13:08 GMT GOP Officials Hope for Stability From McCain - New York Times
New York Times - By ADAM NAGOURNEY and ELISABETH BUMILLER Republican leaders across the country said Saturday that they were worried that Senator John McCain was heading for defeat unless he brought stability to his presidential candidacy and settled on a clear message ... Antiwar Protestor Disrupts McCain Iowa Rally Obama needs 75 percent turnout in Philadelphia, says Rendell Publ.Date : Sat, 11 Oct 2008 22:23:47 GMT Nobel Peace Prize winner wants jobs for the young - International Herald Tribune
International Herald Tribune - AP HELSINKI, Finland: Nobel Peace Prize winner Martti Ahtisaari said Saturday that finding jobs for more than 1 billion young people in the Middle East and Asia will be a major challenge to peacebuilding in the next decade. Video: Ex-Finland President Wins Nobel Peace Prize Nobel Finn Publ.Date : Sat, 11 Oct 2008 13:12:07 GMT YouTube to play full TV episodes with ads - Afterdawn.com
Afterdawn.com - Google has announced that it will begin offering full-length TV episodes through its YouTube platform beginning this week, thanks to a content deal with CBS. YouTube to Offer TV Shows With Ads Strewn Through YouTube beams up Star Trek for long-form video, prominent new ads Publ.Date : Sat, 11 Oct 2008 21:13:12 GMT Display RSS Feeds on Your Website |
PARLOT::Ebooks, Scripts,
Websites, and more... Another powerful reason for making the switch from using the... Read More These are several ways that you can use to persuade... Read More Years ago, when email was just emerging as the incredible... Read More Happy New Year! New attitude? New habits? How about 10... Read More Let me ask you a question, "What is the most... Read More If I sent you an email that said: "The Big... Read More An opt-in e-newsletter is one of the most effective marketing... Read More A strange thing has been happening to newsletters online. They... Read More The neurophysiological dynamics of understanding each email message are very... Read More In Fall 2003, America Online (AOL) released its brand new... Read More As an Online Home Based busy owner you will reach... Read More You've launched your web site. You've implemented a public relations... Read More So you want to start publishing an online newsletter? Why?... Read More Don't overlook your current customers. After all, they're the ones... Read More According to a study by the Winterberry Group, email marketing... Read More There probably isn't a business person alive who hasn't at... Read More Being online for the last five or so years has... Read More Lack of trust is the biggest problem marketers have on... Read More Autoresponders, or responders, are simply programs that allow you to... Read More Another powerful reason for making the switch from using the... Read More Are you dead sure about receiving of all the important... Read More When it comes to your gravy, lumps are bad. When... Read More One of the best and newest tools out there for... Read More Things just got a lot hotter in the hyper-competitive world... Read More Did you know one of the most important tools in... Read More
Adsense
websites
Track Customer Response With an Autoresponder Service
Ways To Persuade Your Web Site Visitors To Give You Their Email Address
Plain Jane Email Equals Flat Results
10 Netiquette New Years Resolutions
The Gold Is In Your Mailing List
A Cool Email Communication Tip
Six Tips for Nonprofit E-mail Success
Writing Newsletters Online: How to Get it Right
Three Phases to Email Sensitivity
5 Things You NEED to Know About Your AOL 9.0 Subscribers
3 Simple Steps on how to Get Unlimited E-Mail Accounts for Pennies a Day
Creating Demand With Email Newsletters
Online Marketing Through Newsletters
Why Your Email Distribution List is Your Best Source of New Sales
Why Email Marketing Matters
What Do Your E-Mail Messages Say About You?
Click for Success!
Five of the Most Powerful Elements In Opt-in Marketing
Autoresponders - One Simple Trick That Will Improve Your Results
Improve Newsletter Delivery with an Autoresponder Service
Six Easy White-Listing Ways... Stop Losing Important Emails!
Lumpy Mail Gets Your Message Through
Top 5 Reasons to Use Autoresponders
Let The Email Wars Begin
7 Autoresponder Marketing Strategies To Automate, Build and Grow Your Business
Affordable and Reliable Web Hosting Starting at $4.49/Month
3 Important Tips to Write Money-Making Autoresponder Messages
Sending autoresponder messages is one of the most powerful email... Read More
Essential Rules For Effective Email Marketing
If you want an email campaign to succeed, you don`t... Read More
Converting More Free Downloads to Paid Customers
Do you give web site visitors the opportunity to download... Read More
Use the ?Reply All? Function in Email Judiciously
Type "email etiquette" into the search bar of any popular... Read More
Build Your Opt-In List Today
There are many services available to help your with building... Read More
Reach Out and Slap Someone
I got my first email account way... Read More
Email Etiquette: How To Send Emails People Will Read
You may remember a time before there was email?a time... Read More
Is Your Email Address Blacklisted?
A lady emailed me yesterday very upset over the fact... Read More
Do Your Autoresponders Drive Your Customers Crazy?
A chained auto-responder is a sequence of emails that gets... Read More
Make Your E-mail Signature File WORK for You
You're probably familiar with e-mail signature (or "sig") files --... Read More
Three Steps To Building A 50K Email List In Less Than 90 Days
One major asset that every internet or affiliate marketer needs... Read More
The Most Simple Way to Mask Your Email-address
We all know that spammers are looking for your email-address.... Read More
Learn The Five Key Steps To Getting Free Publicity For Your Internet Site and Products
1) Website FocusMake sure your site is focused on a... Read More
Yes, Please Do Come In, But Better Watch Your Step!
This little parody, and the comments that follow, were... Read More
An E-mail Promotion Internet Marketing Strategy Works
E-mail promotion Internet marketing can help your home-based business expand... Read More
Why Autoresponders are an Absolute Must
With autoresponders, you never have to lose money advertising again!... Read More
A Lesson In Email: The Money Is In The List... With The Back-End Sales
Firstly, back-end sales is eMail Marketing at its best, so... Read More
All I Really Needed to Know About List Building I Learned From Stephen King!
I have always been an avid reader of Stephen King's... Read More
Using A Simple Idea to Target Your Audience
A wonderfully easy and free concept that many people seem... Read More
Build or Buy--Should You Build Your Own Opt-in Email List?
The easiest way to acquire an email list for your... Read More
Why Use Permission-Based Email Marketing?
The goal of all marketing is to attract interest in,... Read More
Sales Prospecting for Appointments by Email
A few months into the job and Sabrina's cold calling... Read More
22 Simple But Highly Effective Methods To Ban E-mail Opt-In List
Here are 22 simple but highly effective methods to build... Read More
Using Blind Carbon Copy (BCC) For Email Privacy
Need for PrivacyPeople have become hypersensitive about their privacy during... Read More
Three Phases to Email Sensitivity
The neurophysiological dynamics of understanding each email message are very... Read More
Email Marketing |